Browse All Hayden CO Historical Properties for Sale

Enjoy the character of an established Hayden home with the comfort and finishes of a modern renovation. Extensively renovated in 2021, this feels like a brand new home. This is a three-bedroom, two-bath residence that offers hardwood flooring, tall ceilings, and a thoughtful floor plan highlighted by a spacious primary suite with a large private bathroom and walk-in closet. There is also a bonus room off the loft that could make a good office, storage or play room. The kitchen features granite countertops, a gas range, and attractive finishes, while quartz countertops add a polished touch to the bathrooms. A tankless water heater, air-conditioning, and Ethernet wiring throughout the home provide added efficiency and connectivity. Outside, the fenced yard creates a welcoming space for pets, gardening and outdoor living, complemented by a flagstone patio at the front entry. Constructed in 2024, the heated two-car garage is conveniently accessed from the back door or from the alley. Together with over four dedicated off-street parking spaces, the property offers exceptional parking and storage for an in-town home. Original garage plans depicting a potential accessory dwelling unit above the garage are also available; any future use or construction would be subject to applicable Town approvals. The central Hayden location places everyday conveniences close at hand, with the Hayden Center directly across the street and schools, groceries, the post office, restaurants and local gathering places just a few blocks away. This move-in-ready property blends historic charm, quality updates and practical modern features in the heart of the community.

124 N 3rd St, Hayden

$520,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1070541 MLS

Full updates, unbeatable location — this one doesn't come around often. Set just one block from Hayden High School and bordering Hayden City Park, this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath ranch-style home offers nearly 1,600 SF of stair-free, easy living — and it's been completely refreshed top to bottom. Step inside to new flooring throughout, an open floor plan across the kitchen, dining, and living room, and a cozy gas fireplace. The kitchen features new appliances and a pantry, opening to a covered porch overlooking the huge fenced backyard. Major systems are done: a brand-new roof and new Andersen warrantied windows mean true peace of mind for the next owner. Outside, the massive backyard backs directly to the park and includes a new privacy fence (built under a special variance), a new large shed, and a new greenhouse — ideal for gardeners or hobbyists. The oversized driveway offers ample parking plus dedicated space for a trailer or camper alongside the house. Additional highlights include a walk-in closet, an updated bathroom, and a laundry room/office bathed in natural light. Hayden puts you just 25 miles from Steamboat Springs via paved US highway, minutes from Yampa River State Park, and close to local restaurants, shops, and a brewery. A fully updated home of this size, in this location, at this condition — is genuinely rare for the market.

661 W Washington, Hayden

$535,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1069590 MLS

There is something genuinely special about this downtown Hayden home and it shows the moment you arrive. The charm draws you in, and this is a home for someone who wants to shape it into their own. A cabin-style residence on a treed lot with an inviting yard, the character here is immediate, unique wood details throughout, natural light pouring into a spacious living room, and a warmth that's hard to beat. The main level includes a full bathroom and bedroom, with three more bedrooms and a bathroom upstairs. A large deck extends the living space outside, and the two-car garage with an additional stall for smaller toys and equipment handles the practical side beautifully. This one rewards a buyer ready to put in some sweat equity, the layout and the bones are already here, waiting for the right vision. Step outside and a walkable downtown Hayden puts trails, parks, and restaurants right at your doorstep. Just a short drive to Steamboat Springs means more adventure and amenities to choose from. Not to mention, the five-minute drive to Yampa Valley Airport makes this home a great jumping-off point for bigger adventures. This one is worth seeing in person, it's a Hayden gem for someone ready to make it shine.

524 E Washington Ave, Hayden

$945,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1068739 MLS

Historic charm meets rare downtown acreage in Hayden. Set on an exceptional 0.59-acre parcel in Old Town, this residence offers an uncommon blend of character, flexibility, and opportunity. The 4-bed/2 bath home spans 2,288 square feet and is complemented by a detached 6-bay garage with finished 912 sf upper-level rental apartment — a highly desirable feature seldom found downtown. The main home has been well maintained, with a new in-floor heating system, Marvin windows, a freestanding gas stove, and quartz kitchen countertops, while still preserving the architectural character that defines its historic heritage. Classic elements including the steep gable roofline, wood siding, and root cellar, creating a sense of authenticity and warmth that today’s buyers increasingly value. One of the property’s most compelling features is the expansive lot itself. Considerably larger than most Old Town parcels, the level and highly usable grounds offer endless potential for gardens, greenhouse space, outdoor entertaining, recreation, or future expansion. Bonus feature is the irrigation well in the yard providing water for landscaping at no extra charge to the owner. Oversized RV storage is available. Mature landscaping, paved access, and the surrounding historic neighborhood contribute to the property’s welcoming small-town atmosphere. The detached 38' x 44'- 1672 square-foot garage provides exceptional versatility with six-car capacity, workshop potential, studio space, and abundant storage. Above the garage, a separately metered 2-bedroom ADU is currently tenant occupied, creating immediate rental income and added value for a future owner. Hayden's Open District zoning further enhances the property’s appeal, allowing for a broad range of uses including a home-based business, greenhouse operation, etc. — a rare opportunity for entrepreneurial vision. Ideally located in the heart of Hayden, the property is just a short walk to Hayden Public School and Dry Creek Park.

335 S Poplar St, Hayden

$419,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1068029 MLS

Step back in time with this historic downtown Hayden gem, where classic character meets modern versatility. This 1,384 SF three-bedroom framed home radiates the warmth of a bygone era, featuring a sun-drenched living area anchored by a cozy gas stove and a spacious, inviting kitchen. • The property's vintage appeal extends outdoors to a private sanctuary shaded by majestic old-growth trees. A spacious covered deck offers the perfect spot for quiet mountain mornings, while the fenced backyard is ideal for children and pets. The 520 SF detached 2-car garage/shop—complete with alley access and an additional parking space—includes a separate office and workshop. • Located just a short stroll from the local library, schools, an auto shop, and Wild Goose Coffee Shop, this home perfectly captures the quaint, walkable charm of a small town, all while being just minutes from the Yampa Valley Regional Airport.

129 S Poplar St, Hayden

$625,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1067770 MLS

Welcome to this well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home full of timeless charm and character. This inviting property blends the warmth of an older home with the comfort and functionality today’s buyers are looking for. Situated on a large, beautifully landscaped lot, the property is surrounded by mature trees that provide exceptional shade and privacy, creating a peaceful outdoor setting perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Inside, you’ll find a comfortable and functional layout with plenty of natural light and classic details that add to the home’s unique appeal. The spacious family room features vaulted ceilings, and a custom fireplace to add comfort and warmth on those chilly winter mornings. The bonus room works well as an office or craft/sewing room. Exterior features include an attached garage for convenience and a spacious shop in the back with easy access—ideal for hobbies, storage, or workspace needs. This property offers space, character, and versatility both inside and out—don’t miss the opportunity to make it your own.

517 E Jefferson Ave, Hayden

$699,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ S1067604 MLS

This meticulously maintained home in downtown Hayden, Colorado, sits on four city lots and offers an incredible outdoor lifestyle. The expansive yard is a true oasis, featuring a historic two-story 20’x20’ barn (circa 1920) with endless potential, a 12’x11’ chicken coop with an adjacent run, a 6’ privacy fence and a thriving garden space with an 8’x8’ raised bed next to a raspberry patch. Fruit trees, including two cherry, three apple, and two peach, dot the landscape, complemented by mature lilac trees, vibrant flower gardens, and a stunning crab apple tree that bursts into pink blossoms each May. Two patios create ideal outdoor spaces—one stamped concrete with a 7-person spa and a BBQ area, while another 12’x16’ terracotta pavers patio beneath a tall maple tree invites relaxation among the songbirds. The oversized 36’x30’ heated garage, originally a mechanic’s shop, features a half bath, radiant floor heating, and automatic garage doors on two sides. Additional parking includes space for up to eight cars next to the garage and adjacent to the home, an RV/boat/trailer area on the east side of the garage, and another concrete parking pad behind the garage, where a 7.5’x10’ storage shed also sits. Inside, the updated home offers a bright, functional layout with three bedrooms and two full baths on one level. The sun-filled kitchen opens into a spacious living room with hardwood floors, a charming beadboard ceiling, and a traditional masonry fireplace for cozy winters. The primary suite boasts a walk-in closet, a renovated en suite bath, and direct access to the hot tub patio, while the second bath features elegant tilework and a clawfoot tub. Additional highlights include a new furnace, new water heater & a covered storage area for firewood. Located within walking distance to Hayden’s top-rated K-12 school, downtown shops, and restaurants, and just 25 miles from the world-class Steamboat Ski Area, this one-of-a-kind property checks every box!

399 E Jefferson Ave, Hayden

$1,500,000

S1066059 MLS

Exceptional opportunity to acquire the business and real estate of A-1 Liquor in Hayden, Colorado. Due to its US Highway 40 and Walnut Street location, along with great customer service and thoughtful product offerings, A-1 has built a loyal customer base and consistent revenue stream. The operation is community oriented and family owned and operated, allowing a buyer to step into a turn-key, hands-on retail business. Revenue is driven primarily by liquor sales, complemented by tobacco, vape and ice sales with the real estate providing a secondary revenue stream via two leased warehouse bays. All inventory, personal property and fixtures associated with A-1 Liquor are included in the sale, along with the 5,484 square foot retail building located on a 0.32-acre site. Growth opportunities include the potential to expand on-site liquor inventory storage, host tasting events, move into lottery sales, expand tobacco and vaping products and increase warehouse bay rents. A-1 Liquor is the only liquor store within 17 to 25 miles and Hayden is a growing community. Approximately 240 rental units are currently coming online, and additional housing and commercial developments are in the pipeline. Speaking to the large commuter population driving the Yampa Valley and the easy on/off Highway 40 access, A-1 Liquor was voted No. 4 Best of the Boat (Steamboat) Liquor Store for 2025. The combination of business and real estate makes this an appealing acquisition for an industry buyer seeking an additional location or an individual retailer looking to fully leverage the strong customer base and growing Hayden community.

106 E Jefferson Ave, Hayden

$1,098,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ S1064172 MLS

Colonial Craftsman Custom Home – Introducing the historic B.T. Shelton home reimagined! Turn of the century history has been skillfully brought back to life in an unparalleled custom renovation. This two-story home, originally constructed in 1904, is now a 1,760 square foot, three bedroom, two and a half bath modernized masterpiece. The main floor boasts an open floor plan with a kitchen made for gathering family and friends, detailed by KraftMaid all-wood cabinets, luxury vinyl plank flooring, dual fuel range, Silestone counter tops and floating shelves crafted from the original 121-year-old floor joists salvaged during renovation. Upstairs the primary and two additional bedrooms have 3/8” clear glass barn-style shower doors, full-sized mirrors and custom closet systems for ample organized storage. The 628 square foot, two-car attached garage is finished, gas hookup ready and accessed from an electric, remote-activated, security gate entrance off the alley. Above the garage, with a separate entrance, sits a one-bedroom apartment, similarly finished, perfect for multi-generational living or rental income. And, a hidden framed doorway has thoughtfully considered future flexibility, allowing the main residence and apartment to be connected living spaces. The 0.29-acre lot (legally two buildable lots and available for expansion opportunities) has a lush lawn shaded by mature trees creating the perfect setting for lazy afternoons or easy entertaining. Coupled with the downtown Hayden location, within walking distance to shops, dining, grocery and Hayden Center, this custom renovation is history reimagined in the heart of Hayden.

340 E Jefferson Ave, Hayden

Start Your Search

Hayden Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Hayden and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!