Browse All Oak Creek CO Between $500K - $600K Properties for Sale

Check out the VIEW from the very top ... The "Best View" in Stagecoach! If you like nature, it's all right here at your fingertips. Just Wilderness, Wildlife and Mother Nature's best Bluebird Skies. Peace and Privacy at the Top! Inside this beautiful Stagecoach Townhome, you can discover serenity. Unlike any other in the area, this 3-bedroom + enclosed loft, 2-bath home spans over 1,400 square feet and has been extensively remodeled including brand new carpet throughout. Some of the updates that are hidden include: extra insulation throughout (ceilings, walls, and lower floor) reducing electric bills, multi-purpose upper loft with awesome sky views and extra storage, rooftop heat tape installed, plumbed for third bathroom, walkway ramp up to parking lot, and the list goes on. Situated next to the proposed Stagecoach Ski Mountain Area, this is a true year-round retreat in a sportsman’s paradise. Boating, water skiing, and fishing await at nearby Stagecoach Reservoir, while world-class fly-fishing can be found in the legendary tail waters just below the dam. Plenty of snowshoeing and Cross Country Skiing abound in Stagecoach. The town of Oak Creek is simply 5 minutes away for groceries, gas and restaurants. With endless hiking and mountain biking trails, and only 30 minutes to Steamboat Springs or 90 minutes to Vail, this home offers the perfect blend of seclusion, adventure, and accessibility. Come experience life at the top, where peace, nature, and opportunity await. 23015 Schussmark Trail is owner occupied and has been Impeccably Maintained. BONUS: there is STORAGE under the townhome as well as a shared enclosed MUDROOM - perfect for mountain living and your new TOYS! Bring Fido too!

23015 Schussmark Trl Unit C, Oak Creek

$595,000

S1069860 MLS

Private 16.6-Acre Mountain Retreat with Sunset Views Discover the freedom to create your ideal Colorado retreat on 16.60 acres in sought-after Blacktail Mountain Estates. With no HOA or architectural review committee, this exceptional South Valley parcel offers the rare combination of privacy, flexibility, and convenience. The property is ready for your vision, featuring a well, driveway already in place, nearby electric, and paved access all the way to the driveway. A beautiful blend of quaking aspens, Gambel oak, open meadows, and mature treescreates a picturesque landscape with multiple private building sites to choose from. The varied topography allows you to tailor your homesite to capture expansive southern vistas, spectacular western sunsets, or both, while preserving the seclusion and serenity that make this property so special. Located just 11 miles from Steamboat Springs, you'll enjoy peaceful mountain living with quick access to world-class skiing, dining, shopping, and year-round recreation. Routt County zoning allows for a custom single-family home with an attached ADU and accessory outbuildings, giving you the flexibility to create a guest suite, caretaker quarters, workshop, barn, or storage for all your Colorado toys. A rare opportunity to build without HOA restrictions on one of the South Valley's most desirable acreage parcels—where privacy, views, and freedom come together.

28350 County Road 14, Oak Creek

$569,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1069489 MLS

Situated on 0.72-acres, this Stagecoach home is an amazing value for a first-time buyer, or as a second home / investment property. Surrounded by abundant outdoor recreation opportunities, and only 40 minutes to the Steamboat Ski Area, this 2BR / 1 BA home is perfectly situated to live under wide open sunny skies and stunning dark-sky nights. Imagine yourself and friends relaxing around the warmth of the wood stove on those snowy winter nights. Three sources of heating (propane, electric and wood) provide surrounding warmth on both levels. This property faces south with two stories of glass - utilizing solar gain and embracing the surrounding views. The kitchen has granite tile countertops and a breakfast bar backing to the open living area. The primary bedroom is located on the main level, and the second bedroom comprises the upper floor. A log accented entry provides a convenient mud-room, keeping out the elements. The outside of the home boasts a low-maintenance and fire-resistant metal roof, ample deck, fenced yard for pets, and a large storage shed for all of your toys! Luminate high-speed fiber optic is installed to the lot line. Nestled between Green Ridge to the south and the Service Creek Wilderness Area to the north, it is only a 25-minute drive to the town of Oak Creek and 42-minutes to Steamboat Springs. Close to Routt County Road 16 (year-round maintenance), this property has easy access to Stagecoach Reservoir, Stagecoach State Park, and the Flat Tops Wilderness Area. In addition, there are groomed cross-country ski trails just 5-minues away! This home provides a viable way to step into the local housing market and access all that Colorado mountain living has to offer!

21109 Yuma Way, Oak Creek

$515,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1069106 MLS

Delightful single-family home, with the charm of a Hobbit house, located in the historic mining town of Oak Creek, offering a cozy and unique living experience. This inviting 3-bedroom, 1-bath residence features a versatile loft area that can be used as a sitting space or an additional bedroom, perfectly adapting to your needs. The open-concept bottom floor enhances the spacious, airy feel, creating a welcoming space for relaxing and entertaining. Sitting on a generous 0.15-acre lot, the home includes radiant heat and a warm wood stove for comfortable, year-round living. A large shed/shop on the property provides ample storage and workspace for hobbies or projects. Enjoy true mountain living with convenient access to world-class skiing in Steamboat Springs and Vail. Outdoor enthusiasts will love nearby Flat Tops for four-wheeling, snowmobiling, hiking, camping, hunting, and fishing at Stagecoach Lake. Families benefit from top-notch local schools and the peaceful, nature-rich surroundings. This Oak Creek gem combines historic charm, comfort, flexibility, and outdoor adventure—ideal for a relaxing retreat or an active lifestyle.

233 Arthur Ave, Oak Creek

$500,000

S1069373 MLS

Ready-to-Build Homesite with Panoramic Mountain & Reservoir Views Take in breathtaking views in every direction from this exceptional 5-acre homesite, ideally positioned within an exclusive gated enclave below Young’s Peak at Stagecoach Reservoir. With a flat building site, circular driveway already in place, well installed, and electric to the lot, the groundwork has been completed so you can focus on bringing your vision to life. This unique parcel allows for a custom single-family residence, caretaker dwelling, and additional outbuildings, providing ample space for guests, hobbies, and all of your Colorado recreational gear. Just minutes from the water, you'll enjoy effortless access to boating, paddleboarding, fishing, and lakeside recreation, with the Stagecoach Reservoir boat ramp less than a mile away. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the nearby fly fishing, extensive mountain biking, hiking trails, and year-round adventure opportunities. The private community consists of only 12 five-acre homesites surrounded by 34 acres of dedicated open space, with neighborhood trails connecting directly to the public trail network at the Neighborhoods of Young's Peak. A valuable added benefit is the well's participation in a water augmentation program, allowing for outdoor irrigation—an uncommon and highly desirable feature in Colorado mountain communities. Offering privacy, infrastructure, spectacular scenery, and immediate access to recreation, this is a rare opportunity to create your dream mountain retreat in one of Stagecoach's most distinctive settings.

23590 Youngs Creek Way, Oak Creek

$549,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ S1068705 MLS

Rarely available 4-bedroom Eagles Nest townhome overlooks Stagecoach Reservoir with unobstructed lake and mountain views, dark skies for stargazing, and a layout designed to make the most of its stunning setting. One of the best values in Stagecoach with its 4 bedrooms, exceptional storage, RV/boat parking, high-speed Luminate fiber internet, municipal water and sewer, and easy access to Stagecoach Reservoir recreation. Offering an exceptional combination of space, storage, convenience, and value, this property is ideal as a full-time residence, mountain getaway, or rental investment opportunity. Perched above the shimmering waters of Stagecoach Reservoir, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath townhome is a gem. Parking is adjacent to the back deck, making gear unloading effortless after a day on the mountain or the water. This custom oversized deck, reinforced for a hot tub, doubles as your welcoming entry and perfect outdoor living space. The main level features an open kitchen and dining area with granite and hickory countertops, hickory cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, large windows, and abundant natural light. Upstairs, vaulted ceilings and floor-to-ceiling windows highlight panoramic reservoir and mountain views, while the primary suite features its own wood-burning fireplace. A second fireplace creates a warm mountain atmosphere in the living area. The lower level includes three bedrooms and a full bath, providing flexibility for family, guests, remote work, or hobbies. Storage is exceptional, with a large bonus room offering potential for an office, den, or media room, plus a massive exterior-access storage area for bikes, tools, watersports equipment, and mountain gear. It's hard to find another property in Stagecoach that offers this combination of reservoir views, 4-bedroom capacity, storage, amenities, and value at this price point.

30331 County Road 16 Unit 302, Oak Creek

$547,000

S1068012 MLS

Young's Peak Preserve is comprised of twelve 5+ acres lots in a beautiful hidden valley below Young's Peak and has gently sloping terrain, with trees and wooded areas, incredible views and unmatched privacy. From the property you can enjoy views of the Stagecoach Reservoir, Blacktail Mountain, Woodchuck, Greenridge, Stagecoach Ski Area and of course Young's Peak. The gated and secluded preserve has a private trail network that meanders through the subdivision onto 34 acres of open space and connects to the Stagecoach trail system for additional enjoyment. Lot 4 is tucked into the aspen and pines, but still showcases spectacular views and is ready to build and already has a well in place. With easy access from County Road 16, this property is only 18 miles from world-class skiing and the other amenities of Steamboat Springs and is just moments away from Stagecoach State Park, Flattops Wilderness Area and Sarvis Creek Wilderness Area. Boating, fishing, camping, hiking, and snowmobiling are all just steps outside your door. This lot is perfect for anyone looking for a mountain oasis where they can build their dream home on their own little slice of heaven. Come see this amazing property for yourself, the photos simply do not do the preserve justice.

Tbd04 Youngs Creek Way, Oak Creek

$508,000

S1067699 MLS

Character and value differentiate this lot from the others. This 7 acre site features several draws, aspen groves and a seasonal stream creating an incredibly desirable and peaceful setting. Nestled below the surrounding bluffs, the lot is protected from the elements and offers a calming sense of privacy and serenity. An ideal building site/envelope is located at the top of the lot on a bench that provides views overlooking the tree tops to Stagecoach Reservoir and Blacktail Mountain. Water augmentation contract in place with the Upper Yampa District allowing for outdoor irrigation. Many high producing wells in the area, so water is prevalent. An exclusive trail network meanders through the neighborhood leading to the 34 acres of open space that encompasses Youngs Peak. Stagecoach is a recreational paradise with a boat ramp to the Stagecoach Reservoir State Park less than a mile away and National Forest trailheads located just a short distance up the road. Located just 25 miles south of Steamboat Springs, this represents a great value for 7 acres in this location.

23540 Cresent Way, Oak Creek

Start Your Search

Between $500K - $600K Oak Creek Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $500k - $600k properties available in Oak Creek and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!