Black Horse I At Stagecoach Real Estate, Homes, Condos for Sale in Oak Creek, CO

Easy to access, easy to build on large .81 acre Blackhorse I lot with electric running to this area of the subdivision. This parcel has a lovely mix of open aspens and more dense pines allowing for a natural building area towards the front yet surrounded by lush wilderness supplying plenty of privacy and remote living. Just about 10 minutes to Stagecoach Reservoir for fishing, boating, paddle boarding and all kinds of summer and winter fun and only 20 minutes to everyones favorite restaurant, Lupita's, in Oak Creek for tacos and margaritas. You are also less than 2 miles from the Silver Creek trailhead that gives you access to endless outdoor opportunities of the Sarvis Creek Wilderness recreational area. When you need to get your "town" fix head into Steamboat Springs for skiing, biking, fine dining, shopping and so much more. This is a wonderful opportunity to own in beautiful Routt County.

20810 Filly Trl, Oak Creek

$60,000

S1070281 MLS

Peaceful and secluded lot located in Lynx Pass. This property features a fairly flat building site which is easily accessible on improved dirt roads with access to electric available right across the road. The Lynx Pass community is located around 40 minutes from Steamboat, 26 minutes from Oak Creek and 20 minutes from the Stagecoach Reservoir. This tranquil location is the perfect setting to escape the noise and build your dream home in the woods. Surrounded by recreational opportunities, this lot provides easy access to community hiking and biking trails, groomed cross country trails during the winter and a plethora of water activities at Stagecoach during the summer months, making it an outdoor enthusiasts paradise.

33255 Filly Trl, Oak Creek

$38,000

S1069886 MLS

Lot 30 in Black Horse I at Stagecoach is a beautiful opportunity to build in one of South Routt’s most peaceful mountain settings. This gently sloped lot is adjacent to open space, giving it a more private, tucked-away feel with extra breathing room around you. Tucked away in the trees, yet quickly accessible to County Road 16, this is a prime location. Whether you’re dreaming of a full-time home, a weekend escape, or a long-term investment in the growing Stagecoach area, this lot offers a great canvas to bring that vision to life. Located just minutes from Stagecoach Reservoir, you’ll have easy access to boating, paddleboarding, fishing, hiking, biking, and year-round outdoor recreation. The area offers that quiet Colorado lifestyle buyers love, while still being within reach of Oak Creek, Yampa, and Steamboat Springs. With open skies, natural surroundings, and room to create something special, Lot 30 is a wonderful place to settle into the Stagecoach lifestyle.

33415 Filly Trl, Oak Creek

$30,000

S1068761 MLS

Large treed lot on a cul-de-sac overlooking the Stagecoach valley and adjacent to approximately 13 acres of HOA common area and a seasonal stream. This .77-acre lot is located in the Black Horse I subdivision, offers a gentle slope, and is close to abundant recreation, including Stagecoach Reservoir with year-round activities such as boating, fishing, camping, hiking, biking, and bird watching. Nearby attractions include the Nordic Ski Trail, Silver Creek Trailhead (gateway to wilderness trail), the quaint town of Oak Creek, and much more to explore. Stagecoach is approximately 20 miles south of Steamboat Springs, one hour from Vail, and just 5 miles from Oak Creek, where you’ll find a variety of amenities. Affordable lot with electric nearby. Water well and septic vault needed. Access is via an unimproved cul-de-sac, adding to the property’s secluded and private setting. For additional information on the Stagecoach community, visit stage-coach.com and for water/sewer information visit Morrison Creek Water & Sanitation District. A survey is also on file. This peaceful lot offers privacy, views, open space/greenbelt, and excellent value.

20870 Mustang Way, Oak Creek

$75,000

S1068199 MLS

Discover the perfect setting for your mountain retreat on this spacious 0.67-acre corner lot in the desirable Horseback Subdivision at Stagecoach. This flat, buildable parcel offers beautiful mountain and valley views, making it an ideal canvas for your custom home or getaway. Located just 30 minutes from world-class skiing in Steamboat Springs and 15 minutes from dining and entertainment in Oak Creek, you’ll enjoy both peaceful seclusion and convenient access to nearby amenities. Outdoor enthusiasts will love being minutes from Stagecoach Reservoir State Park, featuring a marina, fishing, boating, and a variety of water activities, along with nearby hiking and biking trails. Utilities include electric and Luminate high-speed internet at the lot line. A buyer may drill a well and install a vault system, or explore the possibility of tapping into the nearby sewer main and water supply. This is a great opportunity to purchase an affordable lot in a scenic mountain setting —perfect for building your dream home or weekend escape. Don’t miss your chance to enjoy everything Stagecoach has to offer.

33505 Seneca Trl, Oak Creek

$42,000

S1062691 MLS

Own a piece of the beautiful Colorado back country. Lots 34 and 35 of Black Horse I at Stagecoach are being sold together as 1.02 acres of remote, forested, unimproved land in the mountains. Stagecoach is known for year round recreation including hunting, fishing, hiking, mountain biking, cross country skiing and snow shoeing. The Stagecoach Reservoir is 10 minutes north for lake and boating activities. 20 minutes to the closest town of Oak Creek means you can enjoy the tranquility of the mountains in private. Build your dream home on this land and enjoy the scenery, activities, and serenity that this property has to offer.

Tbd Appaloosa Way, Oak Creek

$62,500

S1062220 MLS

Discover the perfect mountain escape on this .85-acre lot in the Black Horse I neighborhood of Stagecoach, just outside Oak Creek. This homesite backs directly to HOA-owned open space, giving you extra privacy and direct access to the community’s network of hiking and cross-country ski trails enjoyed by all Stagecoach residents. With nearly an acre of gently sloping land, the property offers multiple options for a future build site while keeping the wide-open mountain feel that makes Stagecoach so special. Whether you’re envisioning a full-time home or a retreat close to Steamboat Springs, this lot delivers the space, scenery, and recreation at your doorstep not to mention the incredible Mexican restaurant "Lupitas" in nearby Oak Creek. Fiber optic internet and power are close by. Stagecoach is known for its year-round lifestyle—boating, fishing, and paddleboarding on the reservoir in summer; cross-country skiing, snowshoeing, and wildlife watching in the winter. Lot 97 puts you right in the middle of it.

32960 Maverick Way, Oak Creek

$25,000

S1061201 MLS

Discover your peaceful mountain retreat in the Black Horse I subdivision of Stagecoach, where privacy and natural beauty surround you. Tucked near the entrance of Mustang Way—a quiet, undeveloped cul-de-sac just off year-round maintained Filly Trail—this 0.58-acre homesite offers an inviting canvas for your future cabin in the woods. The lot features a flat, easily buildable site nestled within intermingled aspen and conifer trees, providing natural beauty throughout the seasons. Electricity is conveniently located near the lot line, while a well and vault system will be needed for water and sanitation. Located just 1.5 miles from the Silver Creek trailhead, this property provides easy access into the 44,556-acre Sarvis Creek Wilderness—offering endless outdoor recreation. You're also only about 10 minutes from Stagecoach Reservoir for boating, paddleboarding, fishing/ice-fishing, and summer beach days, and just 30 minutes from world-class skiing, dining, and amenities in Steamboat Springs. Enjoy the tranquility of a wooded setting without total seclusion—nearby homes offer a sense of community while maintaining the feel of a private escape. Whether you're dreaming of a weekend retreat or a cozy full-time mountain getaway, this property presents an exceptional opportunity to create your ideal Stagecoach basecamp.

Tbd Mustang Way, Oak Creek

$46,500

S1059707 MLS

This awesome wooded lot is level making for an easy build. It is located just minutes from the lake and year-round recreation! Filly Trail and Maverick Way are improved roads, with electric and high speed broadband just across the road. Well and vault are needed. Take advantage of this wonderful location with easy access to CR16.

32980 Maverick Way, Oak Creek

$900,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ S1059602 MLS

Tucked into the forest near Stagecoach Reservoir and just 30 minutes from Steamboat Springs, this modern-rustic retreat is the “log cabin in the woods” you’ve always dreamed of—blending rustic luxury, privacy, and year-round adventure. Enjoy total seclusion with the convenience of public water, sewer, electricity, and fiber-optic internet (no well or septic to worry about). Thoughtfully designed and meticulously maintained, this 3 bed, 3 bath home offers 2,570 SF and an exceptional outdoor setup. Hardwood floors, exposed log accents, and live-edge counters highlight the rustic charm, while new lighting, updated appliances, and stylish furnishings add fresh comfort and function. Exterior recently stained, sealed, and re-chinked. The flexible layout is perfect for family or guests, with three distinct living areas—a main-level living room, spacious lower-level family room, and a separate TV/game room with office nook. The main level has a bright kitchen with all-new stainless-steel appliances, peeled log accents, and a cozy gas fireplace. Upstairs is the primary suite. The lower level features the guest bedroom, adorable bunk room with six built-in beds (each with a nightlight, USB port, and outlet), a large family room with brand-new gas fireplace, and walk-out access for easy outdoor enjoyment. The exterior is where this property truly shines: two large decks, massive custom stone firepit, rock-lined path, and curated spaces including a sledding hill called “Giggle Gulch.” A matching 120 SF shed with loft provides extra storage. Surrounded by 13+ acres of HOA greenbelt, pine forest, and aspen groves, the park-like setting offers unmatched peace. Just 10 minutes to Stagecoach Reservoir and close to extensive trails for all-season recreation, this home is a true basecamp. Whether you’re adventuring outdoors or relaxing by the fire, this home delivers. If you need more elbow room, the two adjacent lots owned by the Seller will be offered to Buyer for separate purchase.

21015 Palomino Way, Oak Creek

$42,000

S1058047 MLS

This .78 acre lot in Black Horse I is perfect for building your primary or secondary home. Back lot line borders community open space. Plenty of mature trees and wide open space. Approximately 10 minutes from Stagecoach State Park and Reservoir and approximately 30 minutes from Steamboat Springs. Enjoy all the area has to offer including year-round activities for the outdoor enthusiast including: water skiing, paddle boarding, fishing, hiking, biking, hunting, snow-shoeing, cross country skiing and more. Nearby hiking trails and even a groomed Nordic track exclusively for Stagecoach property owners. Call Listing Agent for more details. If you are considering building your dream home in a peaceful rural setting, this is an opportunity you won't want to miss

33435 Filly Trl, Oak Creek

$915,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ SS3868646 MLS

Nothing compares to that perfect place you have been searching for with endless possibilities. Step into this exceptional home overlooking more than 150 acres of common area open space for serenity at its best. Custom 3 bedroom plus loft plus bonus office/den with two large living areas and expansive views. The main level primary suite enjoys a private bath with double sink, separate shower, jet tub and walk-in closet with custom built-ins. Enjoy the view as you sip coffee in bed on a gorgeous morning. Expansive deck allows for outdoor entertaining with easy propane hook up for your grill. Cross country ski, sled down the hill or take a moonlit snowshoe right from your back door. The area is great for gravel biking, hunting, hiking, or heading to the Stagecoach Reservoir for boating, fishing and more. Only 23 miles from the Steamboat Ski Area and 13 miles from Oak Creek. The owner's have enjoyed so much great family/friend time here in their private sanctuary. Nice open great room with vaulted ceilings, cozy wood stove, wood floors and radiant heat. The kitchen boasts a Wolf Stove, stainless appliances, granite/butcher block counters, custom backsplash all open to the great room. Work from home in the loft as you enjoy the view or for more privacy use the bonus room in the lower level as your home office. Large second family room on the lower level includes a wet bar with plenty of room for a pool table, ping pong or relaxing area for movie and game nights. The lower level gas stove keeps you toasty in winter too. Walk out to the backyard for a game of cornhole, to relax in a hammock, play in the sandbox or tp enjoy the sandhill cranes. This 3076 square foot home sits on 0.61 beautiful acres. The front and back have a sprinkler system and lovely gardens. The new Noble Boiler is 95% efficient to keep the home warm, and the home has a freshly stained exterior. If you have been searching for the perfect mountain getaway, call for a private showing today.

33485 Arabian Way, Oak Creek

$41,500

SS2334038 MLS

Enjoy treed seclusion on this lot just minutes away from the lake and recreational activities. The road to the cul-de-sac is improved (Filly Trail) and a house is under construction on lot 94. Lot is in the cul-de-sac just beyond the construction site. The cul-de-sac portion of road will need improved. Water and Sewer lines are at the cul-de-sac. This has been verified with Morrison Creek Water.

20865 Pinto Way, Oak Creek

$61,000

SS8423542 MLS

This breathtaking .68 acre lot at Black Horse I in Stagecoach is the perfect building site for your dream home. This tree-lined and meadowed lot backs up to open space on two sides creating a private yet open feel. Public water provided by Morrison Creek with tap fees paid and electrical run to the lot. Vault septic permits are still available or public sewer lines can be easily extended. Make Stagecoach your home and enjoy all the recreational opportunities that Routt County has to offer: boating, snowmobiling, skiing, fishing, hiking, and biking to name a few. Minutes away from Stagecoach Reservoir State Park, 30 mins to Steamboat Springs and easy access to Routt National Forest. Stagecoach is an outdoor enthusiast’s paradise! Please visit stage-coach.com to understand building and living in this great area.

33075 Filly Trl, Oak Creek

$53,000

SS3001119 MLS

Easy access to this private lot just off County Road 16 in Black Horse I. This 0.93 acre lot is made for the rustic chap who wants to coexist with the natural surrounding habitat and wildlife. Lined with mature trees and growth that ensure privacy and seclusion to build your cabin or mountain escape, using eco-friendly and off-grid systems that fit into the pristine native landscape. This lot borders common area and is less than 6 miles to Stagecoach Reservoir and a mile from Silver Creek Trailhead with 44,000 acres of wilderness area and national forest. Located 20 miles south of Steamboat Springs (Ski Town USA), Stagecoach is a small mountain community that features a 820 acre reservoir with a plethora of recreational activities to include boating, biking, hiking, paddle-boarding, and renowned trout fishing.

- Lot 20 Black Horse I, Oak Creek

$50,000

S1048194 MLS

Large treed lot on cul-de-sac in Black Horse I at Stagecoach. This lot is within close proximity to the Nordic Ski Trail where you can enjoy cross country skiing and snow shoeing during the winter months. Stagecoach also offers year-round outdoor recreation with the reservoir a short distance away you can enjoy a variety of water sports, there is also a trail system for hiking and mountain biking. Stagecoach is approximately 20 miles south of Steamboat Springs, an hour to the Vail Valley and the town of Oak Creek is 5 miles to the west where you will find a variety of amenities. Stagecoach is the perfect location for the outdoor enthusiasts whether you are looking to build your forever home or a vacation get away. Check out this affordable lot on .64 of an acre!

20870 Pinto Way, Oak Creek

$30,000

SS1699769 MLS

Large treed lot on cul-de-sac in Black Horse I at Stagecoach. This lot is within close proximity to the Nordic Ski Trail where you can enjoy cross country skiing and snow shoeing during the winter months. Stagecoach also offers year-round outdoor recreation with the reservoir a short distance away you can enjoy a variety of water sports, there is also a trail system for hiking and mountain biking. Stagecoach is approximately 20 miles south of Steamboat Springs, an hour to the Vail Valley and the town of Oak Creek is 5 miles to the west where you will find a variety of amenities. Stagecoach is the perfect location for the outdoor enthusiasts whether you are looking to build your forever home or a vacation get away. Check out this affordable lot on .73 of an acre! For additional information on the Stagecoach community go to www.stage-coach.com.

33325 Buckskin Way, Oak Creek

$82,000

SS9597447 MLS

This .63 acre lot in Black Horse I checks all the boxes! A perfect location for building your primary or secondary mountain getaway home. Plenty of mature trees, young aspens, and level terrain with an easy to envision home site from both sides of this corner lot. The electric runs along the lot line with public water and sewer lines right there for you when it's time to build. With year-round access already in place and the 13+ acres of community SPOA land bordering the lot line, this corner lot has everything to offer for the Buyer looking to build their dream home in a rural peaceful setting. The lot has been mitigated of fallen trees and Seller has a survey to share upon contract. Approximately 10 minutes from Stagecoach State Park and Reservoir with Oak Creek and Steamboat Springs just a short drive away. Enjoy all the area has to offer including year-round activities for the outdoor enthusiast including: water skiing, paddle boarding, fishing, hiking, biking, hunting, snow-shoeing, and more. Plenty of nearby hiking trails and even a groomed Nordic track exclusively for Stagecoach property owners. Contact Morrison Creek Water and Sanitation for information regarding tap fees and water and sewer lines. If you are considering building your dream home in a peaceful rural setting that offers public utilities this is an opportunity you won't want to miss!

21035 Palomino Way, Oak Creek

$45,000

SS3341426 MLS

This 0.65 acre tree lined lot is level and ready to build. Located only 12 miles outside of Oak Creek and 25 miles from Steamboat Springs, this is a recreational paradise. Stagecoach Reservoir and State Park is near by, offering hiking, biking, fishing, boating and cross country skiing.

20815 Filly Trl E, Oak Creek

$82,500

SS4849132 MLS

Water and sewer are at the lot line; easy build. This lot is private but also is located on a publicly maintained road. Electricity is 552 feet from the lot line per Yampa Valley Electric. At $40 per foot to dig and install the line, the cost will be approximately $22, 080. This lot is quite flat with a variety of trees including Ponderosa Pines, Lodgepole Pines, Aspens and Spruce. There is a payment to the water and sanitation district of $111.82 every two months for water and sewer infrastructure. Tap fees are approximately $20,000 for water and sewer. Stagecoach offers a quiet life with views and likeminded neighbors wanting to be away from the confines of Steamboat proper. There are a host of activities to keep you outside year-round including hiking, biking, hunting, fishing, boating, XC skiing, and paddle boarding. Stagecoach Lake is 7 minutes away and Oak Creek is 15 minutes away boasting one of Routt County's best Mexican restaurants, Lupita's! Steamboat Springs, a 35-minute drive on publicly maintained roads is easily accessible and offers recreation on the 2nd largest ski area in Colorado, Steamboat Ski Resort. Steamboat Springs also boasts numerous shops, restaurants and free concerts year-round.

33225 Filly Trl, Oak Creek

$25,000

SS3890560 MLS

30 minutes to Steamboat, an hour to Vail: Stagecoach is the perfect balance of peace, quiet and proximity to World Class Amenities. This gorgeous treed and fairly level lot is located in the center of Black Horse | Subdivision in Stagecoach. The Routt National Forest, with access to the Silver Creek trailhead is about a mile away. Stagecoach State Park and Reservoir is up the road and offers: xc skiing, boating, fishing and amazing birdwatching and more. The quiet roads in the area offer some of the best gravel grinding you will find anywhere. Lots of wildlife, quiet and cool mountain breezes will leave you feeling like you are in the middle of nowhere, but no worries you are actually in the middle of everywhere. Get here and get yours before everyone else.

20930 Cayuse Way, Oak Creek

$54,900

S1053731 MLS

Secluded mountain homesite offering peaceful surroundings and beautiful Colorado scenery. This 0.67-acre property offers a quiet natural setting with open landscape and surrounding mountain scenery. A wonderful opportunity for buyers dreaming of building a cozy mountain cabin, weekend retreat, or private getaway in the Colorado high country. Conveniently located in the Stagecoach area with easy access to Steamboat Springs, Stagecoach State Park, and Oak Creek, this property offers the perfect balance of peaceful mountain living and proximity to world-class skiing, dining, and recreation. The surrounding Stagecoach community continues to attract interest with ongoing discussions of future resort development in the area., along with the amazing fishing, boating and snowmobiling. This setting also offers a wonderful opportunity for those interested in sustainable mountain living, with space and flexibility to design an eco-friendly cabin or off-grid retreat that blends naturally with the surrounding landscape. • Secluded mountain setting, Peaceful natural surroundings, Ideal for a cabin or weekend retreat

20935 Cayuse Way, Oak Creek

$32,500

S1056216 MLS

Opportunity to own a piece of Colorado! Nestled in the heart of Stagecoach, just minutes from the town of Oak Creek and a short drive to Steamboat Springs, this spacious lot offers the perfect balance of privacy, adventure, and convenience. Road finished and electrical onsite! Trees surround a clearing for your perfect home spot. Situated on .7 acres, this wooded lot boasts views of the surrounding mountains, and near Stagecoach's many open spaces, BLM trails, and National Forest access. Enjoy endless outdoor activities right from your doorstep—boating, fishing, and paddleboarding at Stagecoach Reservoir, hiking and biking on scenic trails, and world-class skiing just a short drive away. Whether you are looking for a peaceful retreat or a basecamp for outdoor adventure, this lot offers it all. If you have been looking for a great lot in Stagecoach, you can look no further! Water via a well or water cistern & septic by vault.

20850 Mustang Way, Oak Creek

Browse All Black Horse I At Stagecoach Properties for Sale

Black Horse I At Stagecoach Real Estate & Homes