Quick Stagecoach CO MLS Search

Browse All Stagecoach CO Under $200K Properties for Sale

$120,000
S1069929 MLS
Discover a rare opportunity to own 5 contiguous lots totaling 4.42 acres in the desirable Sky Hitch IV subdivision of Stagecoach, Colorado. Comprised of Lots 104, 106, 107, 108, and 111, this unique land package offers exceptional flexibility for investors, future builders, and buyers seeking a strategic foothold in one of Colorado's emerging recreational destinations. Positioned directly on Shay Way, this property provides the privacy, natural beauty, and long-term potential that savvy land investors seek. Surrounded by mature aspen and pine trees, abundant wildlife, and breathtaking mountain scenery, these lots offer a secluded retreat while also presenting a compelling opportunity for future appreciation. With growing interest in the potential development near the Stagecoach Ski Area, this property allows buyers to invest early in an area with significant upside potential. Whether you're looking to secure a long-term land holding, create a private mountain getaway, or position yourself for future development opportunities, this offering checks all the boxes. The 5-lot parcel can be maintained as individual parcels or consolidated into larger building sites, providing valuable flexibility for future planning. Seasonal access with future road improvement possibilities enhances the property's remote mountain appeal while preserving the peaceful setting that makes this area so special. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate proximity to Stagecoach Reservoir and year-round recreational opportunities, including boating, paddleboarding, fishing, hiking, mountain biking, hunting, snowshoeing, cross-country skiing, wildlife viewing, and more. This is Colorado mountain living at its finest. If you're searching for Colorado mountain land for sale, Stagecoach investment property, or a large acreage opportunity with future growth potential, this unique 5-lot parcel deserves your attention.

5 Lots On Shay Way, Oak Creek

$199,500
S1068123 MLS
Discover a rare opportunity to own a 0.50-acre homesite in South Shore at Stagecoach Reservoir with panoramic views of Stagecoach Lake, the Flat Tops, and Blacktail Mountain. Located at 24395 Arapahoe Road in Oak Creek, Colorado, this build-ready lot offers the perfect setting for a custom mountain home, vacation retreat, or investment property with walkable access to the reservoir and nearby BLM land for year-round recreation including boating, fishing, hiking, hunting, and snowmobiling. The property is cleared, professionally surveyed, and soil tested, with grid power available for a cost-effective and convenient build. Included in the sale is an optional fully developed custom home design package, allowing you to skip the typical 12–18 month design and permitting timeline while still maintaining the flexibility to build your own vision. The engineered and stamped plans are tailored specifically to this lot and feature a 1,600 sq. ft. high-efficiency SIPs home designed to capture 360-degree views, complete with a luxury primary suite, expansive glass, and a 16-foot La Cantina sliding door that frames the lake and mountain scenery. The design also includes a 950 sq. ft. attached garage designed as a workshop along with additional two-car covered parking, and high-end specifications such as radiant heat concrete floors, a metal roof, and fire-resistant Hardie siding, along with a Marvin window package selected to maximize views. The seller is also providing a complete “Project Vault” with vendor contacts, SIPs kit pricing, window and door specifications, and estimates for utilities, excavation, and concrete work, eliminating much of the guesswork and accelerating the building process. Why wait one to two years to design and permit when you can secure a property that offers a valuable head start toward your Colorado mountain dream home.

24395 Arapahoe Rd, Oak Creek

$110,000
S1067694 MLS
Tucked away in a peaceful mountain setting, this property offers a rare combination of privacy and accessibility via a county-maintained road, making it far more convenient than many more remote mountain parcels. The lot provides a true “close-in but private” feel, unlike more distant areas that can be difficult to reach in winter or for daily commuting. There is also an opportunity to expand your footprint with two additional adjoining parcels that the Seller would be willing to part with for the right price, creating a total of 6.71 acres with sweeping 360-degree views of forested hillsides and surrounding mountains. The adjacent land includes a conservation easement acreage and open space, with views of the Sarvis Creek Wilderness, preserving a lasting sense of open space and natural beauty. The property is well prepared for future development, with dead-standing timber cleared to reduce fire risk and a gentle, build-friendly grade that allows for an easy driveway installation. Located approximately 4.5 miles from the local fire station, the property may also offer added benefits for insurance considerations. Enjoy the beauty of the surrounding ranches and open land, or explore the nearby trail systems ideal for hiking, snowshoeing, and cross-country skiing. Whether you envision building among the trees or near the open meadow, the property offers multiple scenic homesites to suit your vision. Just minutes from Stagecoach Reservoir, you’ll have convenient access to boating, paddleboarding, and fishing, while remaining within close proximity to Steamboat Springs and the charming town of Oak Creek. The property also benefits from agricultural status for hay production, helping keep property taxes low. Utilities include electric nearby, with water options via well and septic by vault. With access to extensive trail systems, open space, and national forest, this is a rare opportunity to own a versatile and thoughtfully prepared piece of Colorado mountain land.

33170 Wenatchi Trl, Oak Creek

$45,000
S1056926 MLS
Discover the potential of 1.81 acres of raw land, tucked into the scenic South Station II at Stagecoach subdivision. These two lots combine to make a generous footprint for a future homesite minutes from the Routt National Forest. While secluded, the land is quite close to 820-acre Stagecoach Reservoir that provides year-round recreation for outdoor and water sport enthusiasts. Boat or paddleboard on the large lake, or run or bike along the 9.6-mile Elk Run Trail: a gravel trail that winds around the reservoir with spectacular views. Popular hiking trailheads such as Silver Creek and Sarvis Creek are also nearby. During winter time, you can snowshoe, fat bike and ice fish in and around the reservoir. There are also groomed cross-country skiing trails near the Creekside common area. Should you need a change of scenery, jump in the car and head south on Highway 131 to the Flat Tops Wilderness to explore 235,000 acres of prime mountain terrain. At this time, the lots only have seasonal access and a road will need to be installed for year-round entry. The HOA does not allow any recreational type of use for residential lots, such as camping, or temporary structures (tiny homes, yurts, RV's, etc). The nearby community of Oak Creek provides small-town charm with local amenities, while Steamboat Springs is 30-miles away with world-class skiing, dining, and year-round events. Vail and the I-70 corridor are also 1 ½ hours away. Stake your claim in this growing area of Northwest Colorado!

Tbd Springboard Trail, Oak Creek

Start Your Search

Under $200K Stagecoach Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for under $200k properties available in Stagecoach and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!